Skip to main content

HPQ:Chemistry:Post 16:Bonding and Structure:Keith Guy

Question

Which two of these statements is correct when melting ice and silicon dioxide (a giant covalent structure)

A. Strong covalent bonds break within the silicon dioxide
B. Weak intermolecular forces break between water molecules
C. Weak intermolecular forces break between silicon dioxide molecules
D. Strong covalent bonds break within water molecules

Answer

A and B

It is a common misconception that covalent bonds between atoms within molecules break on melting and boiling. Students should understand that ice, water and steam all consist of molecules of H2O. In addition the students should become familiar with four substances, (silicon, silicon dioxide, graphite and diamond), which form giant crystalline structures in which covalent bonds between atoms do break on melting and boiling.

Files

Comments1

Comments

Sign in to post comments

Claire Phillips (not verified)

You are absolutely right about this being a problem area for students. I would almost want to just ask about one substance at a time to tease out the misconceptions. 

if i asked "What has caused water to melt at 0 degrees C"

A. Water has weak bonds so they are easily broken.

B. Water has a covalent structure so the bonds are strong.

C. Water has a molecular structure so the forces between are weak.

D. Water has a combination of weak and strong bonds.